Wiegmann, Matti/ Neyer, Jürgen/ Stein, Benno (2026): Detecting Foundational Narratives in Parliament Speeches
Narratives are a common tool for expressing and consolidating the identity and beliefs of mgroups of people. In politics, foundational narratives describe deeply held beliefs about power and collective identity which political actors often use tacitly to convince supporters and consolidate power. Although these narratives are highly relevant to understand political discourse, their algorithmic detection and quantification is a new venture in NLP research, as it requires knowledge of, and competent reasoning about, political discourse. In this paper, we formulate the task of foundational narrative detection as a one-class classification problem. We present a new dataset comprising English speeches from the European Parliament that have been annotated by expert political scientists. We also propose an effective classification approach, evaluating the impact of model selection, task formulation and explicit knowledge on classification accuracy. However, due to the complexity of the task and the influence of biases and subjectivity, we do not consider direct classification, whether by human or LLM, to be the ultimate solution for labelling political texts according to narratives. As an alternative, we present two prompt strategies with comparable performance that classify political texts indirectly by reasoning over generated pro and con arguments.
Read more